by Aimee O’Connell
I have recently become aware of a book just published, Autism and Holy Orders, touted as a long-overdue resource for helping autistic men navigate the process of priestly formation, ordination and service in the Church. I could not wait to start reading… until I hit the foreword by Scott Hahn.
Scott Hahn’s name always brings a smile to my face. I have an entire shelf devoted to his books. I have attended his conferences and speaking engagements. I relish with guilty pleasure every single Dad joke he has made and refer many, many people to his writing, as I feel he has a gift in being able to explain Church doctrine in a way that is memorable, relevant and relatable to anyone. I don’t know him personally, but it’s no exaggeration to say he is a part of my Catholic fabric.
The foreword made me gasp.
In an instant, this well respected, well recognized, NON AUTISTIC writer / speaker / scholar, to whom so many look for guidance and encouragement, dismissed the condition of being autistic as a fad, a marketing ploy, a source of confusion. His flippant tone made me want to shrink, mask, camouflage, hide. If he said this in one of his public talks, any autistic person in the crowd would wish to become instantly invisible.
He goes on to qualify his thoughts along the lines of some of his best and brightest students have had autism, and it pains him to see them suffer needlessly from a lack of understanding. His departure from Dad jokes to full-on irony hit me like a hard smack in the face, and I’m still not laughing.
The rest of the book, I’m sad to say, followed suit. You can read my review here. On the one hand, it’s a consolation to know that a book like this has a very narrow target audience, so Dr. Hahn’s insensitivity won’t necessarily be felt by as many people as it might if he wrote this in a more mainstream book. On the other hand, how many autistic people know what sort of attitude Dr. Hahn holds toward us, and perpetuates – knowingly or unknowingly – through his example?
Certainly, Dr. Hahn is entitled to believe and feel whatever he does. It is not my place to police his comments. However, it is within bounds to remind everyone who is not autistic that autism is no picnic. We aren’t broken, yet people still look at us that way. Alexithymia and sensory anxiety still make it very difficult for us to feel we are “enough” in the eyes of God, let alone the eyes of the Church. Our intellect may know that God loves us as we are, but our bodies send signals of constant doubt which we have to consciously recognize and counteract if we want to maintain any kind of spiritual life. It is a thousand times worse when our community sends us signals that feed this doubt (… such as when a renowned Catholic speaker belittles autism as a fad). And, it’s amazing to see that even the people who consider autism a disability still speak about it as though they know everything about it, yet have zero knowledge of what it’s like from the inside, or any seeming desire to truly listen to those of us who talk openly about it it (… especially if they so quickly dismiss that as attention-seeking).
Dr. Hahn: It’s not funny. I’m not laughing. I pray that you may grow in compassion, offering Jesus’ prayer on your behalf: “Father, forgive him; he does not know what he is doing.”
